Why Trying Shoes On Still Matters (Even If You Know Your Size)

Because fit isn’t just about numbers — it’s about feel.

With online shopping everywhere, it’s tempting to think:
“I know my size — I’ll just order them.”

But shoes are one of the few things where trying them on properly still makes a real difference. Not because you don’t know your feet — but because shoes (and feet) are far more individual than we’re led to believe.

Here’s why taking the time to try shoes on is still one of the best things you can do for comfort, confidence, and long-term wear.

Your Feet Are Unique (Even From Each Other)

Most people don’t realise this, but:

• one foot is often slightly bigger
• arches can differ left to righ
• insteps vary
• toes spread differently

Trying shoes on lets you feel how both feet sit — not just whether the size sounds right. A shoe that fits one foot perfectly but pinches the other will never become a favourite.

Sizing Isn’t Standard (Even Within the Same Brand)

A size 38 is not a universal truth.

Different styles within the same brand can fit differently depending on:

• toe shape
• heel pitch
• strap placement
• leather softness
• sole construction

Trying shoes on means you’re choosing based on how they actually fit, not what the label says.

How a Shoe Feels When You Walk Matters More Than How It Looks Standing Still

Standing in a shoe tells you very little.

Walking reveals:

• whether your heel slips
• if your toes grip
• how the sole flexes
• if pressure builds over time
• whether the shoe supports your natural stride

That “just okay” feeling in the mirror often becomes “I can’t wait to take these off” an hour later.

Your Feet Change Throughout the Day

Feet naturally:

• swell with heat
• spread with movement
• relax after standing
• respond to hydration and activity

Trying shoes on later in the day — and walking in them — gives you a much better idea of how they’ll feel in real life, not just first thing in the morning.

Good Shoes Should Feel Right Straight Away

One of the biggest myths in footwear is “they’ll just need breaking in.”

Quality shoes should feel comfortable from the start:

• no pinching
• no rubbing
• no pressure points
• no need to “push through”

Trying them on properly helps you recognise the difference between a shoe that will soften beautifully — and one that will never quite work.

Expert Fitting Saves Time (and Regret)

When you try shoes on with guidance, you’re not just choosing a style — you’re learning:

• what works for your foot shape
• which designs support you best
• what features to look for next time
• which styles to avoid altogether

That knowledge carries forward into every future shoe purchase.

Final Thought

Knowing your size is helpful — but knowing what truly fits you is even better.

Trying shoes on isn’t about pressure to buy. It’s about confidence, comfort, and choosing pairs you’ll genuinely love wearing. 

If you ever want honest advice, a proper fit, or just a second opinion, pop into our shop in Mairangi Bay. We’ll help you find shoes that don’t just look good on the shelf — but feel right when you walk out the door.